Skip to content
Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered. Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered.
  • About
    • Our Work
    • Values
    • Team
    • Jobs at OCI
    • Ways to Give
  • Program Areas
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • North Sea
    • United States
    • Global Industry
    • Global Public Finance
    • Global Policy
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Publications
Donate
  • Get Updates
    • Share on Bluesky Share on Bluesky Bluesky (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Twitter Share on Twitter Twitter (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Instagram Share on Instagram Instagram (opens in a new window)
    • Share on LinkedIn Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Facebook Share on Facebook Facebook (opens in a new window)
Donate
  • About
    • Our Work
    • Values
    • Team
    • Jobs at OCI
    • Ways to Give
  • Program Areas
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • North Sea
    • United States
    • Global Industry
    • Global Public Finance
    • Global Policy
  • Blog
  • Press Releases
  • Publications
    • Get Updates
    • Share on Bluesky Bluesky
    • Share on Twitter Twitter
    • Share on Instagram Instagram
    • Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn
    • Share on Facebook Facebook
Go to OCI Homepage
Current Affairs
Published: July 01, 2009

A Nuclear-Tainted and Oil-Soaked Renewable Energy Agency?

  • Latest from OCI
  • Blogs listing
  • A Nuclear-Tainted and Oil-Soaked Renewable Energy Agency?
    • Alternative energy Blog Post Current Affairs Middle East renewable energy
Andy Rowell

When not blogging for OCI, Andy is a freelance writer and journalist specializing in environmental issues.

andy@priceofoil.org

irena-launchSo the United Arab Emirates has won the race to host the new International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) beating off competition from Bonn and Vienna.

Never mind that the UAE has the highest per capita carbon footprint in the world, a fact that had attracted strong opposition from other countries. Never mind that the UAE is a large oil and gas exporter.

Never mind that the new Agency is headed by a French civil servant and the UAE and France have recently signed nuclear agreements.  If you believe the spin put out by the UAE in its glossy website to support its candidacy, it wants to be seen as a global hub for renewable energy.

But it is still having to fight off its critics.”Many see that there is a contradiction between us being one of the largest oil exporters in the world and our seeking to house the agency,” Reem al-Hashemi, a state minister, told the AFP news agency in an interview last week. “On the contrary, this confirms the commitment of a fossil fuel exporter to the enhancement of renewable energy. Since we export energy, we want to export all kinds of it,” she added.

Despite the rhetoric, the UAE remains one of the top oil and gas producers and has a huge vested interest in controlling any renewable agency.  The UAE is trying to placate its critics by arguing that the Agency will be located in Masdar, a 22-billion-dollar city near Abu Dhabi that will have zero carbon emissions.

However, the person elected to head IRENA is France’s Helene Pelosse, a French ministerial official who beat challengers from Denmark, Greece and Spain. It is Pelosse’s appointment that is now central to accusations that the nuclear industry is trying to hijack the renewable energy agency so that it can include nuclear power as a renewable technology.

Adding to the rumours is the fact that France, which recently signed a nuclear co-operation agreement with the UAE, supported Abu Dhabi’s bid to host the Agency.

Eric Martinot, lead author of the REN21 Renewable Energy Global Status Report and a Worldwatch Institute senior fellow, argues that if Abu Dhabi was selected, IRENA would be “nuclear-tainted”.

“UAE has expressed its intentions to rapidly become a ‘model’ for promoting nuclear power,” Martinot wrote in an open letter to renewable energy supporters. “[Choosing Abu Dhabi] raises the question of whether IRENA will be an effective change agent for renewables (i.e. promoting renewables instead of nuclear power), or will be merely an appendage to a nuclear agenda.”

Many IRENA supporters had believed that the best option would have been for Bonn to host the Agency with Hans Jørgen Koch, Denmark’s leading renewable energy policy expert for the last three decades, as a head.

Pelosse hit back against the nuclear accusations in an interview before she was elected, by saying “The idea that IRENA would be tainted by nuclear interests is simply wrong: firstly, [nuclear] is not in its statutes. Second, there already is an international organization in charge of nuclear energy. There is no way IRENA is ever going to deal with nuclear energy.”

We will have to wait and see as to what happens, but we do know that nuclear-proponents have long argued that nuclear should be seen as a renewable technology.

Oil Change International | Data Driven, People Powered.
Donate Get Updates
Back to the top
  • Keep in touch

  • Oil Change International
    714 G St. SE, #202
    Washington, DC 20003
    United States

    +1.202.518.9029

    info@oilchange.org

    • Share on Bluesky Bluesky (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Twitter Twitter (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Instagram Instagram (opens in a new window)
    • Share on LinkedIn LinkedIn (opens in a new window)
    • Share on Facebook Facebook (opens in a new window)
  • Quick links

  • About OCI
  • Our Values
  • Jobs at OCI
  • Ways to Give
  • Media Centre

  • Publications
  • Press
  • Associated websites

  • Big Oil Reality Check
  • Energy Finance Database
  • Permian Climate Bomb
  • Site map
  • Privacy policy

Copyright © 2025 Oil Change International. Web design by Fat Beehive